Review Form for CIKM2009
Manuscript's Background Information
Conference/Journal Name
Manuscript title
Authors' Name
Authors' Affiliations
Authors' Emails
Manuscript ID
Reviewer's Name
Decision
Evaluation of work and contribution?
Strong Accept
Accept
Weak Accept
Neutral
Weak Reject
Reject
Strong Reject
Significance?
Strong Accept
Accept
Weak Accept
Neutral
Weak Reject
Reject
Strong Reject
Originality and novelty?
Strong Accept
Accept
Weak Accept
Neutral
Weak Reject
Reject
Strong Reject
Readability and organization?
Strong Accept
Accept
Weak Accept
Neutral
Weak Reject
Reject
Strong Reject
Technical quality?
Strong Accept
Accept
Weak Accept
Neutral
Weak Reject
Reject
Strong Reject
Overall recommendation?
Strong Accept
Accept
Weak Accept
Neutral
Weak Reject
Reject
Strong Reject
Confidence
Strong Accept
Accept
Weak Accept
Neutral
Weak Reject
Reject
Strong Reject
Summary
Comments to author(s)
Summary of positive points and negative points.
Confidential comments to PC members
Confidential comments.
Summary of review (to author(s) and PC members)
Summary of review.
Nominate for best paper?
Yes
No
Nominate for student award?
Yes
No
Would you recommend this paper as a poster?
Yes
No
Final Confirmation
I have read the above agreement?
Please type 'agree' here